I checked an early volume of my climbing diary and discovered that I climbed this baby on August 19th, 1979 with Bill (of Bill's Bad Bolts fame) and Ed Foley. We went on to climb the W Face of Toog where I apparently found a good #4 stopper placement. Go figure! I think I did Thundering in 1977, however, and forgot to write it down. The poison oak wasn't around in those days!