New Route Discussion: What is good/valid etc.

[clink]

I hope they show up soon!

Me too.   

[mynameismud]

Give me a few months.

[JC w KC redux]

New thread to discuss the merits of what is a good route, what is worthy of being bolted, what is the value of a stared route.

Link to where this started for a bit more history on the topic.

http://www.mudncrud.com/forums/index.php?topic=2177.new#new

I was playing on a rainy day and wanted to see the origin of this thread. It says it is missing or unavailable to me.
Well! I Never!
What's up Mud? 

[F4?]

Same fate as my Retro-Bolting thread I guess.

[mynameismud]

Not sure, will have to look into.  F4 will definitely have the mods delete all your posts.

[F4?]

I can never be silenced!!

[NOAL]

As I remember, the link does not work because the original poster deleted the thread.  Anybody else remember that?

He also deleted all of his comments on this thread. 

[F4?]

Bummer, it’s a great idea to write out what aspects go into a new route.

I remember Mr. Mud said the color of the moss= rock quality.

[mynameismud]

I think Noal is correct. 

[JC w KC redux]

I think Noal is correct.  

I was asking because K Queener makes a comment early in the thread that makes it sound like he started it but Mr Mud's post is the first one. 

Kat just pointed out that Charles is listed a bit downthread on page 1 - so this must have been the infamous "living room" thread.

Thanks! and Here's Mud in Your Eye!

[mungeclimber]

Noal is correct. JC pm me if you need something specific. I copied parts of the original.

[F4?]

Mungie, do you have the part about using the power drill?