...I am proud to say that he gave both of us a desert rat grade (drg) of 4.9 out of 10. Really high marks for a first timer....
I finally stopped laughing enough to respond to this.
While it is true that Caleb and Geoff started out OK (although they never reached even a Desert Rat Grade of 4 mind you), they eventually plunged to a truly, embarrassingly low score.
They showed up with a ton of enthusiasm, but, at least in Geoff's case, not enough clothes for nights in the teens and low twenties (I bet that that won't happen again):

And great attitudes, willing to learn from the only 10/10 desert rat I've ever known:

When on their first day we woke up to 35 mile per hour winds and butt-ass cold temperatures, I took them to the only (only!) spot in Josh that is always sheltered and warm (Corral Wall). They got right into business:


And later in the trip (their last day) they did one of the must-do, iconic Josh climbs (at least if one is camping in Ryan Campground): Headstone Rock:



But see, the thing is, they both made a major, major faux pas, right in the middle of the trip and right in the middle of the desert. A sniveling act of cowardice that was so major, so extreme, that they plunged to a Desert Rat Grade of (gasp, sigh) LESS THAN ONE. Bill and I disagreed at first (he gave them a 0.9 D.R.G. and I gave them a 0.7 - we eventually settled on 0.8 as their end Desert Rat Grade).
And that's it. From low to basement in three days.
I sincerely hope they do better next year
