The rock on Sticky Monkey is so good I figured this thing was well worth a go.
The rock may be decent on that line and it might go but I think what Gavin is getting at is aesthetically how good is it and is it as good as the other routes at that crag? I can see Cooper's point that it would add some variety.
This particular project to me is a reflection of Clink's aesthetics. Clink likes those steep bouldering style starts. With that said each of us that works on new routes find features that we find appealing. I can respect why initially he was drawn to that section of rock. Another cool Clinker style route is Shadows of Madness down by Maniac's delight. It's a fun and quality route with a similar steep start and engaging climbing all the way to the anchor.
When we are putting up new routes sometimes we dont always get it right. If things appear to be going in that direction there is nothing wrong with cutting your losses and then being responsible and cleaning up.
I went out a couple of weekends ago and looked at some potential new routes. A couple.of things checked the boxes for what to me makes a good route but ultimately they did.not check all the boxes. In one instance, over 90 ft ? Check. Good rock quality? Check. Interesting features? Not really. Short vertical sections with potentially long low angle sub 5.6 climbing. I spent a couple of hours sitting looking ,contemplating, and passed. I felt good about my decision.
Like Gavin said maybe TR it first. I have no problem with previewing like this if it helps to make a good decision.