Machete Direct gets one star for the first ascent team, and one star for being able to view Shake and Bake?
Oh, by golly, Machete Direct has 3 stars?! It must get the 3rd star for joining the West Face, which goes to the top, but doesn't have a star.
Was this because one of the FA teams was famous and the other team was...?
For myself, having done the West Face route a year before Machete Direct, I considered the four pitches a variation to the West Face.
I also liked the later added direct/direct start, bypassing the oak tree and eventually combining the first two pitches to avoid the hanging belay.
My favorite memory was a night ascent with Geoff Norris. He forgot his headlamp and we brilliantly had waited for a full moon, which doesn't clear the ridge for a few hours after sunset. So the leader had the light and the follower used braille. By that point we about had the route memorized. We didn't tell our boss and faked being fully alert during work.
If Machete Direct(2.49 stars) gets 3 stars, then Shake and Bake, Son of Dawn Wall and 55 other routes deserve 4.
Just making noise, like babies and old men do.