Well we went back yesterday and climbed both Book of Leon and Chubby Rain, both were excellent. Noal had commented that people were being surveyed as to which route they liked better. First of all, I would like to say that both were highly enjoyable.
Both my partner and myself without hesitation would have to say that Book of Leon takes the prize. That last pitch is what sealed it! Plus the fact that it is a multi pitch is a bonus. Enjoyed the second pitch also, not many pitches in Pinnacles that are strictly gear protected, so that was pretty cool too.
Kudos to all who contributed to putting both these fun stellar routes up!