Brad,
I do not wish on my worst enemy the kind of hell that you will receive over the next year.
"Too many stars"
"Too few stars"
"How could he downrate ____"
"If that's 11b, then Foreplay must be like 14a"
Grades are subjective and people forget that. When a person climbs too much in one area, all the routes feel overgraded. If a person is new to the area, many of the routes may feel impossible. Grades are about consensus and I think you did a good job at trying to get as many opinions as possible. People tend to forget that guide book authors put grades in as a guide, not as the absolute grade. Nevertheless, people will complain.
As for routes like Power Point, 12a? 11a? (I think Mr Mud is sandbagging) Who knows? More importantly: Who cares?
I always thought that a route like that should merely have a V-grade, because it's impossible to tell what the route grade would be. You are done with the hard stuff in the first couple of moves.
Alas, I don't have a copy yet. But as soon as I get one, you'll hear all my complaints
