I made changes to the Full Circle description just now.
It got its first full, onsight ascent yesterday. I gave Joe (not "D," this Joe is not on this site that I know of) a copy of the topo, but with the ratings removed.
He and his wife thought the pitches were 5.9+, 5.10b, and 5.9+. He thought three stars for sure. Gavin and I trust our ratings pretty well (Joe's very strong and has climbed almost all of the multi-pitch Balconies routes with seemingly little effort). Note also that Gavin's friend Janice (listed as part of the FA) thought that the first pitch was "three-star" worthy.
Based on the above, I changed the first pitch rating to 5.10b (even Jim McCon. had given it that). And there's no way I could ever go with three stars, so I bumped it to two.
We'll see how any of this changes (if at all) by the time I get to documenting the West Side for the guidebook.