I led Forgive and Forgoat last Wednesday with Gavin and John present.
With no information ahead of time I'd have rated it 5.10a or b. It's harder than The Wet Kiss, technically harder than Lava Falls (although much better protected) and, by my estimate, two grades harder than Dangling Participle, another 5.9 that Gavin established recently on Punctuation Pinnacle.
Gavin followed my lead (John was saving up for a lead of the gut-wrenchingly runout route Piece of Ewe). Upon finishing, Gavin agreed that 5.10a was fair, told me that Goat Riddence was the same grade, and was specific that Sheep Sheer was a grade harder than these.
Interestingly, Laura had led Sheep Sheer and Steve had followed it over the PCAD weekend. They were both quite certain that it was 5.10b. So I changed that route to fit all of the above.
EDIT: And I should add too that John didn't seem to have any issue with these ratings. Maybe either or both of them will chime in with their thoughts?
And you should go do them; all three are great additions.